Monday, June 11, 2012

Birchbox June Box - Review, Pictures, Swatches


Guess what?  This is my 4th Birchbox!  That's right. It passed the three strikes and you're out litmus test.  Sure the box with the laundry detergent was almost a deal killer, and the box with the baby poop green thank you note stationery was bordering on gross, I still kept my subscription.  Why?


I know that, from past history, and seeing other reviews, that Birchbox, out of all the monthly subscription boxes in the $10-$15 dollar range would provide me with the most useful items, the best customer service, and the easiest on line shopping experience out of all the boxes I have used.  I am now officially ready to say, YES. Birchbox is a decent monthly subscription service and I'm willing to share my referral link for this service.  


Now you all might be thinking; "Big deal. Sharing your referral link will just get you free stuff from the company"  And you would be almost correct. Sharing my referral link will earn me points if people click on that link and decide to subscribe.  Yes. That is true.  With those points I can get up to $10 off any order I place at Birchbox, I could even use it toward a free box for a month.  But if I hated the service I wouldn't really benefit from giving out my referral link because, what's the point of getting referral points to a service I think that sucks?!  Seriously.  You might notice that this is the only beauty subscription service in which I have shared my referral code.  I'll also provide regular links to Birchbox in this review should you choose not to sign up though my referral code.  I'm totally cool if you go that route.  My referral code will be listed only once.  The rest of the Birchbox links in this post are neutral and will not garner me any points or special favors from the company.


OK.  Moving ON.


This month I was pleasantly surprised by the box that showed up in the mail.  This months theme was travel, and the Birchbox team included products that cater to your "inner jetsetter"  Multi use products, full size cosmetics and even a little extra to get you through TSA inspections.  


Let us start with the box.  You'll notice that this month only 4 samples were included.  The Birchbox website states that you should expect 4 to 5 same sized products every month.  Well, this is one of those months where toy get nay 4.  However, Birchbox never has made the promise that you would receive full size items, so receiving a full sized Stila One Step Bronze is quite nice treat.  The retail for this its is $36.  That's pretty awesome since I spent only $10 on the entree box.


The Stila One step Bronze is a three in one bronzer. It's a bronzer, primer and serum.  I love the light gel texture of this bronzer. I love that I can apply it o my skin BEFORE a light foundation or in lieu of a foundation and I like the way it feels on my skin.  Now in the swatch above I'm sure you are all horrified, but that is one and a half pumps on only part of my forearm.  If applied properly, the brown mud oompa loompa look fades away and you are left with the sheer very light bronze color that looks very natural.


The box also included a Sunscreen. This one is from Coola. It's called the Cucumber matte Mineral Face SPF 30.  I haven't opened it yet because it looks like a one time use sachet, but it sounds interesting.  I personally have issues with physical sunscreens making me break out, but I'll try it once in the interest if science to see how it works. I like anything that can deliver a matte finish.

The Juicy Couture perfume sample is just not my cuppa cuppa, so that will go in the giveaway box.  I do kind of wish they wouldn't include perfume samples, but every now and then they include one that is really nice and I end up finding anew scent I really like.


The next and last item is theBalm Cosmetics Staniac in Beauty Queen.  I had a full size tube in the past that I liked a lot, but just lost it along the way. This is a sample see but a little goes a long way.  A full size tube retails for $17 so it's not over the top expensive. Staniac has a nice gel like formula that gives a blueish red color that is easily blendable into the cheeks. It provides a nice natural flush for most skin tones., although fair skin will benefit from this the most and as a lip stain it is decent.  


The flavor isn't great but it's not awful. It fades about as well as other lip stains do, but I will say, apply this before a long flight and when you land you'll look just as pretty as when you boarded the plane.


The "Lifestyle Extra" this month was not a tea bag, laundry detergent or hideous note card.  This month is was a plastic "ziploc style" bag from a company named Tili.  They are sold in packs of 9 or 12 and retail for $8.49-$9.49.  This bag is the exact size allowed by the TSA for carry on of liquids (one quart).  The bag has a cute pink and blue leopard print design and a place to write your name, should you be traveling with multiple people and need to keep track of your stuff.  There are a few things that I can see as potential issues with this bag. a) It is opaque.  I was under the impression that the TSA wanted to be able to see what was IN the bag.  The only way to see IN this bag would be by opening it.  Not cool, if you packed it a specific way and some ham handed TSA agent is pawing through it.  b) The bag is expensive.  9 bags for $8.49 is 94 cents a bag…or you could spend $4.39 on 38 ziploc brand bags that have no design, but are clear and those will run you about 11 cents a bag.  Your choice….but I think I'll stick with the no frills version. I have no desire to make anything prettier for the TSA.  Just my 2 cents.

OK.  DO I recommend Birchbox?  Well. I'll say that ONLY if you are a sample junkie and ONLY if you have $10 extra bucks to spare each month then YES!  Go for it.  If you love me that much you'll sign up though my referral link HERE.  If you still love me but don't want to give me referral credit you can sign up for birchbox by clicking above on any of the other birchbox links in this post.  They are referral link free.

I still maintain that putting $10-$15 a month aside and using it at the end of the year or every 6 months to buy one super luxe item is better than all the sample boxes in the world, but hey, to each her own.

53 comments:

  1. Oh, I didn't get the Stila Primer! FIngers crossed that I will get that in a future box. It looks great! I got a hair mask instead of the primer (but I am happy with the hair mask as well). Also, did not realize that the TSA wanted the bags to be clear? Good to know! A great month for Birchbox! :)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi! Yep. TSA states "1 quart-sized, clear, plastic, zip-top bag;" I was a bit confused when I saw the bag was opaque. http://www.tsa.gov/311/

      Delete
    2. Yeah,was hoping for that bronzer or self- tanning samples - nothing... It was my second birchbox, not that exciting...

      Delete
  2. I usually don't look at previews or unboxings of Birchboxes because I like to be surprised when I receive mine, but after reading your take on BB5, I wanted to see how you felt about Birchbox. I'm excited to receive mine, hopefully it shows up today!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hopefully you get a good box. Reading the comments below makes me nervous for you.

      Delete
  3. oh my eff I want to try taht stila forever sooooo badly I makie no sense right now. Mine shipped. If I don't have the stila you'll hear me scream from 4 hours away

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Well Brooke? Did you get the Stila?

      Delete
    2. nope =( it arrived today. I got a full size Eyeko liner that it pretty awesome but I was wanting the Stila! I'm taking my band-aids and going home.

      Delete
  4. I loved this months birchbox! I got the stainiac, a stretch mark cream (bbblah!) some kind of anti-aging moisturizer, (wont use it but will gift it to a coworker), a birchbox man sample (john varvatos cologne) and a box of band-aids.

    Now, my stainiac and the bandaids were my favorite part.

    Before you think that is a sarcastic remark on my part- the band-aids were super exciting!!! They are Cynthia Rowley designed band aids and pretty cute, and I am ALWAYS needing a damn band-aid and can't ever find them... and the ones I have that are easily reachable are Disney band-aids for the little guy... sooo... you know how awesome THAT is for a grown ass woman to have Lightning McQueen on her arm. (ha!)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. You see!? I would have been happy w/ the band-aids too. I am in the same predicament. although my band-aids have Wolverine on them. :-)

      Delete
  5. Instead of the Stila, I got an Eyeko Fat Stick eye pencil in a deep slate/black. It is nice for those of you who can use them, but the one area I am extra-sensitive is my eyes, so I will give it to my daughter. I also got the stain, which I love, 2 Comodynes self-tanner towelettes, a John Varvattos cologne sample (for my "Birchbox Man", it said, but I am happily single), the baggie, and a tube of Likewise SPF 50 sunscreen. It does seem like a pretty good value to me too, and I love samples and surprises, so I will be interested to see what comes in the future. FYI, I am signed up as my real age of 46 (which apparently helps determine what we get).

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Aww. sorry your eyes are so sensitive. I hear that eye stick is kinda cool. The key is changing your age to the key demographic. I changed mine to 25 last month. LOL

      Delete
  6. I think I got the crapbox this month. I got the Stainiac, but I also got some brush cleaner, hair defrizzer, men's cologne sample [Wha?!], two self-tanning facial towelettes [double wha?! I'm already too dark to use my NC35 MAC Studio FX this summer] and the bag. Needless to say I was not impressed. Had I gotten a box like the one you and others got I would be much more happier. I'm going to give BB another month to see if they redeem themselves.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I would have like the brush cleaner but if that was sent instead of the Stila Bronzer I would not have liked my box as much. I am perplexed why this service is so hit or miss.

      Delete
  7. According to my tracking info, my birchbox will arrive today. I normally like to be surprised, but I had to read your post to see what you got! I hope I got the Stila bronzer! I have been dying to try it and I like the way it looks in your swatch. We'll see! fingers crossed!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I hope you got the bronzer too! Let me know.

      Delete
  8. My box was such a letdown after seeing what was in yours. I got band-aids, the stainiac, a hair mask that I will never use, and a moisturizing face mask which I am happy with. However, I also received my glam bag today as well and believe it or not, my glam bag was amazing for me this month so I guess the sub services really are hit and miss as to what they give you in a given month.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. What was in the glam bag this month? I quit that service after three tries. It just wasn't for me.

      Delete
  9. I enjoyed your post today and the long look at your Birchbox loot. I am going to check out this Stila bronzer again because I have never worn it under foundation! Thanks for the tip.

    I'm also with ya on the Stainiac lip gloss.... I really am a lipstick or sheer lipstick gal, but I think the Stainiac is a top gloss. From an industry standpoint, this seems like a great opportunity for the Balm to promote their product. I really wouldn't test a lip gloss on my lips inside a store, so word of mouth recommendations (no pun intended) are probably important.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Actually you can mix it w/ foundation or you can apply it on top or under foundation. It depends on the effect you are going for.

      Delete
  10. I also got the Stinkbox this month. I did get the Stainiac (such a small size, I can barely see it), some peach mineral bronzer, the 'prerequisite perfume sample' and a box of 20 designer bandaids. Whoo hoo! I canceled my subscription. I'd rather save the $10. and buy a nice lipstick or a Zoya polish. I think I'm done with sample subscriptions; they were fun for a while, but the bloom is off the rose, to quote Shakespeare.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Smart move. No sense in paying for a box of "junk". That $10 a month will go toward something you actually want and like!

      Delete
    2. I got the same stinky box. What I think is so uncool is that some people got boxes worth $30 or $40 and than others (like us) got product that is not even worth the $10 we paid. I just about flipped my lid when I saw the "designer" Band-Aids. Really? I guess it's not as bad as the sandwich bag or the men's cologne sample. The perfume sample would be free at Sephora (all you gotta do is ask.) This was my first box and I'm so disappointed that I'm canceling.

      Delete
  11. For the second month in a row, I'm getting a headband/hairband product, which is sooo useful on my 2-inch-long hair. Seriously, how much more clear can I be when I fill out the surveys and say "CAN'T USE THIS."

    I've really been wanting to try that Stila bronzer too, so I am pretty bummed out that mine is 4 tiny sample packs, another perfume sample, and said useless hairband. This is month 2 for BIrchbox, so if I can get something killer out of month 3, 2 out of 3 months might make me stay on.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. DUDE! Birchbox. Lindsey cannot use hairbands. Stop freakin sending them to her. That's so lame. Sorry about that! That would piss me off too! If you don't get something killer next month will you cancel?

      Delete
    2. If it's even only slightly killer, I will give it 4 tries. That full-size Stila eyeliner my first month really won me over, especially after receiving no useful cosmetics from Beauty Bar. I switched to Birchbox after seeing people getting all those full size nail polishes and other lovlies that I was hoping Beaty Bar would provide.

      It's official though that it's on the chopping block. I got 2 self-tanning towelettes, and the tiniest sample ever of Jouer moisture tint- .07 oz! Weeee. I am actually leaving for vacation on Saturday, but I got nothing I want to take with me. Not even a 1 quart bag.

      Delete
  12. I've been pretty happy with Birchbox - I renewed for year two. I really only *loved* a few of the boxes, though. It was fun and they do have good customer service.

    ReplyDelete
  13. I love the Stila One STep Bronze, I used it all last summer. I mix a half pump with my foundation for just enough color to look natural and not cakey like powder bronzer. I LOVE my May Glossybox!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I'm glad you liked your glossybox. It seems to have had some amazing product in it!

      Delete
  14. My Birchbox isn't set to arrive until later today, but I had to peek online, because I'm impatient. I'm getting a crap box - headband, a brightening mask, self-tanning towels, Supergoop SPF (I'd actually like to try this), and the Stainiac. No Stila bronzer, or even Bandaids - wtf! Looks like I'll be cancelling after this one.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Supergoop is superb...just throwing that out there! lol

      Delete
    2. Well. Did you try the headband? It looks kinda cool actually.

      Delete
    3. I'm in CA right now, so the hubby took pictures for me....Good hubby! I'll definitely be posting something up about both boxes when I get back & hopefully glossybox will be there too.

      Delete
  15. This was a really good month for both Birchbox & MyGlam on my end. How shocking is that? Me having something GOOD to say about both boxes in a month is...just odd. Of course I'm not there because I'm in California but my dear husband sent me photos of each & I'll show them off when I get back. I even think mine beats yours this month! WOAH! I got a headband from Mod Cloth instead of the plastic baggie & got the Stila stay all day 10-in-1 hd beauty balm, stainiac, Juliette Has a Gun Not a Perfume, & Melvita Floral Water. I'm thrilled & haven't even seen it yet!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I know. A very good month for subscription boxes. I'm pleased. I wanted to smell that Not a Perfume perfume. It looks intriguing! Oh and I purchased a full size floral water from Birchbox. :-)

      Delete
    2. Well that's a good sign!!! I just love the name...a lot. I'll let you know what I think.

      Delete
  16. I just rejoined Birchbox this month after taking a couple months off and I got a great box. Bandaids, lip/cheek stain, Kelly VanGogh shampoo and conditioner, rose water mist and the best part....a sample of Dr.Jart+ BB cream! I have been wanting to try this for ages!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Oooh. Nice box indeed!! Glad they hooked you up on your return box.

      Delete
  17. i got the stila one step bronze and am super happy with it! its actually something that i would never have bought on my own. i also looove the stainiac. im thinking of getting it full size. other than that i got the tanning towelettes (which im afraid of because im quite pale), a taylor swift perfume sample (which is quite lovely), and a luna bar. i just wish i had gotten a little baggie instead of food, but it was good.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I would have preferred the Luna bar. Those things are delicious!

      Delete
  18. I really liked my Birchbox this month! I got the stila one step bronze, the balm Stainiac, the tanning towelettes, men's cologne sample, and plastic baggie. The men's cologne sample is the only thing that won't get used. I'm impressed with the bronzer - it works well as a primer for my BB cream and looks quite natural.

    ReplyDelete
  19. I loved my birchbox this month too! :) I was also lucky enough to get the Stila one step which I wanted ever since seeing the preview video. Next month I might just not read any previews or other people's blogs/vlogs before getting my box so itll be a surprise I can't be initially disappointed lol..

    but yeah I am so pleased with birchbox, especially after I won blog contest for them for the ojon products. I can't wait to try those when my shampoo runs out.

    I also got the stainiac which I really enjoy. I haven't used it on my cheeks yet. I just got a random blush for a giveaway and have been using that for now..I wanted a Tili bag but got a Luna bar instead (which was yummy). I bring snacks to work everyday so I wanted a reusable zip lock bag since I haven't been to the store haha...and lastly I got Taylor Swift's Wonderstruck fragrance which I actually really like. I just wish we could get like a small bottle of fragrances because the little vials get annoying..esp when they don't have a spray cap.

    If you are interested in reading about my products I got, I made a blog post and youtube video on it. I'm pretty new to blogging, so any tips would be helpful :)

    Thanks in advance if you do decide to check out my blog!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Please leave a link to your blog here in the comments (even though it says not to) I would love to see your review!

      Delete
  20. My birchbox contained the stila bronzer, almost 1 oz melvita rose floral water spray, theBalm stainiac, sample of taylor swift wonderstruck perfume, and the tili bag. i'm not sure how i feel about the bronzer yet.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I love the floral water. Have you tried that yet?

      Delete
  21. Sure you are happy. You got the full size makeup item. If I had gotten that, I would have been pretty happy as well. What did I get? A perfume sample of the tiny kind they give out for free in dept stores (surprise, surprise--BB loves to toss in cheap perfume samples), Stainiac (great, but everyone got that), a tiny sample of a dark peach bronzer designed for women with olive skin or darker (BB knows I am a light skin caucasian--it is in my profile), and bar soap. That's right--bar soap! My lifestyle extra was band aids which, sadly, almost outshone the rest of the box. That is a sad box all the way around--crappy products and crappy value compared to the others I've seen. I'm surprised you would post your referral link and say you recommend BB without going into detail about how everyone gets a different box and just because you got a good one, in the same month, someone else could get screwed. Speaking as that someone else who did get screwed in June, I'm very unhappy with BB. Strongly thinking of cancelling, if they don't get their act together quick! I don't mean to sound angry at you personally or be offensive or anything. I just really, really think you need to add a few disclaimers about how BB can be inconsistent and disappointing to many subscribers. Give readers all the info they need to make a fully informed decision.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Wow. You certainly sound very angry with me. The tone in your comment comes across as fairly hostile towards me. I have no qualms with recommending the BB and using an affiliate link because this is based off of my OWN experience. Anyone who has read past reviews can see that everyone seems to get different boxes. I am not responsible for the quality of the boxes other people receive nor will I make excuses for the boxes people receive. Please see my DISCLAIMER for more information. Thank you.

      Delete
    2. Pink Sith--I hope you got my previous response to your reply, even though it isn't posted. As I tried to explain, I was angry with Birchbox and not with you, so if I came across the wrong way, I am sorry. I have no reason to be angry with you personally. But I also think I have every reason to be unhappy with Birchbox and I wanted to express that so anyone reading this post would hear that there is another side to the story. That's all.

      Delete
  22. Hi, I just posted a review of my June Birchbox ( a bit late I realized) and linked to your post as an example of a June Box that received different items http://bit.ly/birchboxjunereview. Hope you don't mind.

    ReplyDelete
  23. I was so excited for my first box...and extremely disappointed once I opened it. Really? - a little tin candle, a Ghirardelli chocolate, a perfume sample (That I can get everytime I go visit the beauty counters for free), a 0.07 oz moisturizing tint, a hair detangler and protector), and a Vasanti face rejuvenator. I really can't see why there would be any excitement other than getting something in the mail. Visit your beauty counters and you will actually get more and make a new friend. Ipsy at least gives you a free bag and I think their package is better!

    ReplyDelete

Please leave a message, comment, thought, opinion.
Please No SPAM. I mean the non canned meat kind. I'll just delete your comment.
If you wish to be added to my Link Love Page please send me an e-mail directly at heyelvira (at) pinksith (dot) com. If you wish to sponsor or send me PR, please contact me directly at heyelvira (at) pinksith (dot) com.
Comments with a blog link or website link will be deleted unless it is relevant to the post. I decide what is relevant. Comments not relating to the post, comments attacking me or others commenting will be deleted as well. I do encourage active debate. That means if you disagree with me I will not delete your comment, however if you are disagreeing just to be a troll or just because you want to rile people up, your comment will be gone.
Sorry for the long disclaimer. I've had some "issues" with comments recently.
Thanks!
P.S. If you wish to send me actual SPAM (The canned meat kind) I will gladly accept it via the US Mail, UPS or FedEx.

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...